A Picture is Worth 1,000 Words – What is a Video Worth? Student Perceptions of Video and Screen-recorded Feedback
James Tsatsaronis
School of Life and Environmental Sciences, University of Sydney
Feedback is an essential component of high-quality educational experiences. However, student perceptions to feedback are often critical of the detail, relevance or timeliness of feedback they receive. While feedback on assessment is most often delivered as text, there is a growing appreciation of using multimodal feedback, including audio, video or screen casting, in feedback dialogue.
My exploration of multimodal feedback was prompted by a recent institutional update to Canvas, which introduced video and screen-recording capabilities for feedback. In Semester 1 2025, I decided to experiment with these features. While I had previously provided audio feedback, a multimodal approach – combining video with screen recording – offered even greater potential for providing feedback on multimedia assignments.
I implemented this approach to feedback in an advanced biochemistry unit at the University of Sydney, where students create a five-minute pre-recorded video presentation as one of the assessments. As students submitted a video assignment, providing written comments alone may not adequately relate that feedback to specific aspects of the assignment itself. I provided video feedback for 51 students, with my recordings ranging from about 2.5 to 6.5 minutes. In some cases, the length of my feedback video was longer than the submitted assignment from the student. To structure this feedback, I used a five-part feedback template adapted from Henderson and Phillips (1), shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Video Feedback Template adapted from Henderson and Phillips (1).
| Component | Description | Example feedback |
|---|
| Salutation | Conversational/informal greeting, include student and marker name | “Hi [Student], this is James, I’m trying something different and giving you some recorded video feedback” |
| Evaluative summary | Acknowledge student’s work and give broad statement | “Thank you for your submission, overall you’ve [done a really great job/put a lot of effort in]” |
| Orient to student work | Brief statement that recapitulates the submission to orient the student to the feedback | “You started off your presentation by talking about the background of Gateway cloning” |
| Detailed feedback for each video section | With student submission on screen, move slider and comment on positive and negative aspects of the submission. Pause at key frames and use narration and the mouse cursor to indicate areas of focus. Use web browser tabs to show key literature when correcting any fundamental misconceptions | “In preparing for this presentation, I think you might have overused text. The intention was in this assignment to convey meaning mostly through drawings and diagrams, like here in your section for the experimental workflow” |
| Valediction | Acknowledgement and relational work | “Thanks again for your submission, please let me know if you have any questions, otherwise best of luck for the final exam” |
A key benefit to this approach was in the detailed feedback section. With the student's submission being recorded on my screen, I could drag the slider of their video, pause at key frames, and give specific feedback on how they had conveyed structures or mechanisms. Each feedback video ended with an acknowledgement; usually a good luck message for exams, along with an invitation to ask questions or seek clarify on the feedback provided. These videos were intentionally designed to prioritise authenticity and support relationship building. I recorded all the feedback videos in one take and adopted an informal, conversational tone. My perspective was that these should not be highly edited, perfectly polished pieces of instructional media, but rather, they should resemble an in-person conversation with the student about their work.
After feedback and marks were returned to students, I surveyed students using a questionnaire adapted from the Community of Inquiry instrument that evaluated their perception of the feedback according to dimensions of social, cognitive and teaching presence (2). Students (15/51, 29% response rate) rated items from all dimensions highly, with the highest ratings observed for items relating to social and teaching presence. Students identified three main themes related to the feedback. They identified that 1. the feedback helped them understand their strengths, 2. helped focus their attention on the most important aspects of their work, and 3. gave them a sense of personal connection. Prominently, 100% of students agreed that the video/screen-recorded feedback “addressed areas for improvement, I still felt supported and trusted by my instructor.”
Student responses to open-response questions further emphasised these themes, with many reporting that they felt a closer personal connection to me as the grader. Other students commented that they found the feedback easier to understand and absorb, and that it was clear, specific and personalised. Several noted it felt kind and respectful, describing it as “comforting and encouraging.” Many expressed gratitude for “taking the time” to give feedback this way. The student responses collectively emphasised how video feedback delivered in this modality can foster positive student perspectives towards feedback dialogues.
Adopting this mode of feedback did not come without challenges. Giving feedback of this type requires a quiet location and active endorsement, particularly if the feedback is being provided by tutors or casual academics. However, despite these constraints, this approach shows promise to nurture richer conversations between students and teachers regarding their work.
References
1. Henderson M, Phillips M. Australas J Educ Technol 2015;31(1):51–66.
2. Arbaugh JB, Cleveland-Innes M, Diaz SR, Garrison DR, Ice P, Richardson JC, Swan KP. Internet High Educ 2008;11(3-4):133–136.
About the author
James Tsatsaronis is an Education-focussed Lecturer in the School of Life and Environmental Sciences at the University of Sydney. james.tsatsaronis@sydney.edu.au
This article first appeared in the ASBMB Education Feature of Australian Biochemist Vol 57 No 2, August 2026, pages 15–16.