Assessment Workload – It’s Not About the Number
Fiona Carroll
La Trobe University
Mapping assessment numbers across the Bachelor degrees in Agriculture and Biomedicine at La Trobe University showed that full-time students at first year level complete on average 55 assessments per semester; this is reduced to 30 in later years. It should be noted that from the data it is unclear how many of these tasks are completed as learning tasks during classes. However, assessment concerns are universal, and when presenting this data, educators frequently start justifying these decisions, whereas management suggest we’re over-assessing.
There is no clear definition of what over-assessment is, or indeed discussion of its impact in the education literature. Indeed, it seems that over-assessment is a somewhat nebulous term mostly used in relation to workload.
As assessment in higher education has shifted from large summative exams to ongoing assessment, pedagogical advantages have been indicated for frequent low stakes assessment tasks, particularly in online and blended learning environments (1,2). However, it becomes easy to see that in our 12-week semester, weekly low stakes assessment across four subjects plus additional summative tasks, results in high assessment numbers. I have not yet explored any correlation between task number and workload, and this will likely be highly variable. However, I strongly feel that we should shift the discussion to focus on the quality of assessments rather than the quantity.
It is well-established that assessment drives student behaviour (3,4) and an increasing tendency to incentivise task completion to drive student behaviour leads to an assessment-driven curriculum. As such, the quality of assessment design and the need for learning to occur during task completion becomes paramount as students prioritise tests and assessments over general weekly study (5).
Despite a nominal grade being assigned, low-stakes assessments are frequently intended to be formative. Formative assessment essentially supports learning as opposed to summative assessment that measures learning that has occurred (6). Formative tasks provide feedback that informs and potentially improves teaching and curriculum design and aids the learner to identify strengths and weaknesses while providing feedback for improvement (6).
If regular low-stakes tasks are embedded in learning materials it is important to define their purpose. What is the desired learning outcome? If tasks are meant to be formative, then are they promoting learning? Considerations should include: Are outcomes used to modify teaching or learning activities? Do tasks provide feed-forward feedback students can use to improve? Do students engage with feedback and use it to improve their learning? Are they given an opportunity to do so? Are the stakes so low or the workload so high that students are not engaging with the task and simply guessing? Overall, are assessment tasks promoting and achieving learning at the desired level?
Another consideration is the complexity of low-stakes formative tasks. Consider, for example a pre-laboratory class quiz. If used as laboratory preparation, it is likely we want poorly performing students to engage with the feedback and achieve a threshold mark before they complete the laboratory class. Similarly, tasks completed in class where help is readily available typically result in high scores. However, this doesn’t mean that all low-stakes assessment tasks should generate high scores. Indeed, one could argue that they are low-stakes so students can afford to try and fail, as this promotes learning. If students easily achieve high marks in a task does this give them a false impression of their ability and more importantly, expectations for subsequent summative tasks?
There is no one-size-fits-all approach to assessment. Different people and different disciplines use different tasks to achieve different outcomes. However, the need to have quality assessment tasks designed for, and achieving defined learning outcomes, is something we should all strive for.
Finally, is 55 tasks in a semester over-assessing? It is impossible to put an optimal number on assessment tasks. Indeed, if we focus on quality design and analysis of outcomes, we may find we can achieve similar outcomes with fewer, better designed tasks. However, quality assessment design, validation and review require a lot more peer collaboration and staff time than are typically allocated for these tasks. Addressing this is a more worthy workload conversation than reduction in assessment number due to over-assessing.
References
1. Holmes N Assess Eval High Educ 2015;40(1):1–14.
2. Morris R, Perry T, Wardle L. Rev Educ 2021;9(3): e3292.
3. Biggs J, Tang C. Teaching for Quality Learning at University. 3rd edition, 2007, McGraw-Hill Education.
4. Ramsden P, Ramsden P. Learning to Teach in Higher Education. 2003, Taylor & Francis Group.
5. Hattingh T, Dison L, Woollacott L. Australas J Eng Educ 2019;24(1):14–24.
6. Bennett RE. Assess Educ Principles Policy Pract 2011;18(1):5-25.
About the author
Dr Fiona Carroll is a Lecturer in the Department of Biochemistry and Chemistry, La Trobe University, Melbourne. f.carroll@latrobe.edu.au
This article first appeared in the ASBMB Education Feature of Australian Biochemist Vol 54 No 3, December 2023, pages 25–26.