Shifts in Student Behaviours During COVID-19: Impacts of Social Interaction on Academic Integrity
Ann Rogerson
Faculty of Business and Law, University of Wollongong
Institutional data management of academic integrity cases and types can reveal patterns of both reporting and student academic integrity related behaviour. Previous institutional reporting from 2017–2019 demonstrated that cases of poor academic practice identified in the early years of higher education can be remedied by targetted and structured intervention programs (1).
Results from cases logged during 2020 and 2021 which were impacted by the switch to remote delivery teaching and local lockdowns revealed some differences in student behaviour when compared to academic misconduct cases from previous years. Of particular note is the reduction observed in cases from first year undergraduate students, and a marked increase in instances of collusion by students in other years. Collusion cases primarily fell into two categories – those influenced by technology and others that were the consequence of students gathering, studying and taking exams in the same location as lockdown restrictions eased.
In trying to determine the reasons for the reduction, initial investigations indicate that it was a consequence of first year students having little opportunity to form and build the new social connections that can influence cheating behaviours. There could also be the influence of shifting teaching to remote formats and changes to traditional assessments which has impacted not only first year students, but students in later years of study. We have to remember that we are now coping with more than one cohort of students who have only studied remotely rather than on campus – this has changed social dynamics and consequently some of the ways students are behaving. What was recognised is that for large cohorts it is difficult to manage large groups of students with varying degrees of poor academic practice in a process that is designed to manage a smaller number of individual cases. As a result of this recognition, our institution is introducing newer and simpler reporting for cases of poor academic practice as a way of addressing behaviour through interventions that have been demonstrated to work.
With students beyond the first year of study there was a marked shift from purchased materials to instances of collusion. This involved the effects of sharing site use such as Chegg (2) in addition to the use of gaming networks to communicate with other students during online assessment tasks. Further collusion cases became evident as lockdown restrictions eased in the Spring session (July–November 2020, and the first half of 2021) where students gathered in small numbers permitted under the COVID restrictions to undertake study or assessment tasks. This resulted in higher levels of similarity of content and errors identified using text matching available through services such as Turnitin®.
In trying to address some of the possibilities of collusion in online exams has seen online proctoring/invigilation tools adopted by some institutions to provide one alternative to monitoring in-person/on-campus examinations. There are a range of tools or software solutions available such as Proctorio® and ProctorU, which cover a range of services including identity validation, browser lockdown, IP address comparisons, recorded monitoring or synchronous live monitoring, but have limited interface points to existing learning management systems or require an additional platform setup. It is apparent that these technological methods of monitoring students may be a useful alternative for on campus text-based examinations, but are not necessarily as user friendly or practical for content that requires assessment of calculations, formulae, numeric or chemical calculations.
The COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in changes to teaching that requires us to continue refining the way we teach, assess work and manage cases of academic misconduct (2). As educators, we also need to reconsider how we are explaining academic integrity and, in particular, the influence of social connections on collusion and sharing behaviours in light of the evidence now available on cheating behaviours that have arisen via the global pandemic.
References
1. Rogerson AM (2019) Centralised electronic systems for managing student academic misconduct: evidence from Australia. European Network for Academic Integrity, Lithuania.
2. Lancaster T, Cotarlan C. Int J Educ Integr 2021;17(3): 1–16.
About the author
Professor Ann M. Rogerson is Professor in the School of Business at the University of Wollongong and Academic Lead of UOW’s institution-wide Assessment Reimagined initiative. She also chairs the UOW Course Quality Committee and Academic Integrity Advisory Group. A former Deputy Dean (Education), her academic leadership spans assessment innovation, curriculum transformation, quality assurance, academic integrity and responsible use of generative AI in higher education. Her research focuses on academic integrity, assessment design, and educational technologies. Ann holds a Doctor of Business Administration, Master of Education in Higher Education, Master of Management and is a Senior Fellow of Advance HE. annr@uow.edu.au
This article first appeared in the ASBMB Education Feature of Australian Biochemist Vol 53 No 2, August 2022, pages 15–16.